From Classic to Creative: The Best Pizza in Ohio Ranked

1. Adriatico’s Pizza

Adriatico’s Pizza is a serious contender for the best pizza in Ohio, especially if you’re craving that classic, New York-style slice. Forget fancy toppings and artisanal crusts; Adriatico’s focuses on doing the basics really, really well. I’m talking about a thin, foldable crust with just the right amount of chew, a tangy tomato sauce that isn’t too sweet, and generous amounts of cheese that stretch for days.

I know, I know, it sounds simple, but that’s the beauty of it. They don’t try to reinvent the wheel; they just make a damn good pizza. If you are looking for pizza in Newark Ohio, this is not the place, as it is located in Columbus.

It’s the kind of pizza that makes you want to grab a stack of napkins and eat it standing over the sink. No frills, just pure pizza satisfaction.

Here’s why Adriatico’s stands out:

• The crust: Perfectly thin and crispy, yet strong enough to hold all those toppings.
• The sauce: A classic tomato sauce with a hint of herbs and spices.
• The cheese: A generous blend of mozzarella and provolone that melts perfectly.

2. Dewey’s Pizza

Dewey’s Pizza is another strong contender for the title of the best pizza in ohio. With multiple locations, it’s pretty accessible, which is always a plus. I’ve been to a few different Dewey’s, and the consistency is impressive. You know what you’re getting, and it’s usually pretty good. They have a solid menu with some interesting specialty pies, but you can always build your own if you’re feeling creative. It’s a bit more upscale than your average pizza joint, but the quality reflects that.

I haven’t personally tried any pizza in newark ohio from Dewey’s, but I’ve heard good things about the pizza newark ohio location. I’ve heard that the service is great and the atmosphere is really nice. I’ll have to check it out sometime.

Dewey’s is a reliable choice when you want something a little nicer than your typical takeout pizza. It’s a good spot for a casual dinner with friends or family. The ingredients always seem fresh, and the crust has a nice chew to it. It’s not the cheapest option, but it’s worth it for the quality.

3. Yellow Springs Brewery

Okay, so Yellow Springs Brewery might not be the first place you think of when you’re hunting for the best pizza in ohio, but hear me out. It’s a brewery first, sure, but their pizza is surprisingly good. It’s more of a relaxed, casual vibe than a dedicated pizzeria, which can be a nice change of pace. You can grab a beer and a pie, sit outside, and just chill. It’s a great spot if you’re looking for something different than your typical pizza joint. Plus, who doesn’t love pizza and beer?

I remember going there last summer. The pizza was decent, but the atmosphere was what really sold it. Sitting outside with friends, good beer, and some okay pizza? Can’t beat it.

Here’s why it’s worth checking out:

• The beer selection is fantastic, obviously.
• The pizza is a solid option for a casual meal.
• The outdoor seating area is perfect for warm weather.

I wouldn’t say it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had, but it’s definitely a solid choice, especially if you’re already planning on visiting the brewery. It’s a nice bonus to have some decent pizza available while you’re enjoying their beers. I’ve heard some people say that the pizza in Newark Ohio is better, but I haven’t tried it myself.

4. Crust

Crust is another contender for the title of best pizza in ohio, and it’s easy to see why. They’ve got a few locations now, and each one seems to have its own vibe, but the quality is always consistent. It’s not just about throwing some toppings on dough; they clearly put thought into the whole process. I think that’s what makes them stand out from the crowd.

They’re not afraid to experiment with flavors, which is cool. You can get your standard pepperoni, sure, but they also have some interesting combinations that are worth trying. It’s a good place to go if you’re feeling adventurous. I’ve heard some people say it’s the best pizza in Newark Ohio, but I’ll let you be the judge of that.

I really appreciate that they use fresh ingredients. You can tell the difference when the tomatoes actually taste like tomatoes and the cheese is good quality. It makes a big difference in the overall taste of the pizza.

Here are a few things that make Crust a solid choice:

• Consistent quality across locations
• Creative and unique flavor combinations
• Fresh, high-quality ingredients

5. Harvest Pizzeria

Harvest Pizzeria is a strong contender for the best pizza in ohio, and they’ve got multiple locations to prove it. They’re not just slinging any old pie; they focus on using local and sustainable ingredients. This means the flavors are fresh and change with the seasons. It’s a step up from your average pizza joint, and you can really taste the difference.

I’ve been to the one in German Village a few times, and it’s always a good experience. The atmosphere is cool, and the staff is friendly. It’s a great place to grab a bite with friends or family. They also have a decent selection of craft beers, which pairs perfectly with their pizzas.

If you’re looking for something beyond the usual pepperoni, Harvest is worth checking out. They have some unique combinations that are surprisingly delicious. Plus, knowing you’re supporting local farmers makes it even better. While it might not be the cheapest pizza around, the quality justifies the price. I haven’t been to the location in Newark, ohio, but I’ve heard good things about it. I’ll have to check it out next time I’m in the area.

Harvest Pizzeria is a great option if you’re looking for a pizza that’s a bit more upscale and focused on quality ingredients. It’s a nice change of pace from the standard chains and offers a unique dining experience.

6. Borgata Pizza Cafe

Borgata Pizza Cafe is a real gem. It’s definitely a contender for the best pizza in ohio, and it’s got a loyal following for a reason. I’ve heard people rave about their unique flavor combinations, and the atmosphere is supposed to be super chill. It’s not just your average pizza joint; they seem to put a lot of thought into their ingredients and recipes. If you’re looking for something beyond the usual pepperoni, this might be your spot. I’ve been meaning to try it out myself, especially since I’ve heard they have some interesting craft beer pairings too. Plus, it’s always good to support local businesses, right?

I’ve heard that Borgata Pizza Cafe is a must-try for anyone serious about pizza. The word is that they use fresh, high-quality ingredients, and their crust is perfectly crispy. It’s supposed to be a bit pricier than your average pizza place, but the quality makes it worth it. I’m planning a trip soon to see if it lives up to the hype.

I’ve also heard that if you are looking for pizza in newark ohio, this is the place to go.

Here’s why people seem to love it:

• Creative toppings
• Fresh ingredients
• Relaxed atmosphere

7. Joe Maxx Coffee Company

Okay, so Joe Maxx Coffee Company might seem like an odd choice for a list about the best pizza in ohio, but hear me out. While they’re primarily known for their coffee (obviously), their pizza is a surprisingly delicious contender, especially if you’re looking for something a little different in Newark, Ohio. It’s not your typical greasy slice; it’s more of an artisan, thoughtfully crafted pizza that pairs perfectly with a good cup of coffee.

The crust is thin and crispy, and they use fresh, high-quality ingredients. They have some pretty interesting topping combinations, too, going beyond the usual pepperoni and sausage. It’s a great spot for a casual lunch or a quick dinner, and the atmosphere is super chill. Don’t expect a traditional pizzeria experience, but if you’re open to something new, Joe Maxx is definitely worth checking out. It’s a unique experience that combines two great things: coffee and pizza. What’s not to love?

I was skeptical at first, but I was pleasantly surprised by how good the pizza was. It’s not trying to be anything it’s not, and that’s what makes it so good. It’s a simple, well-made pizza that’s perfect for a quick bite.

8. Sbarro

Okay, so Sbarro might not be the first place that comes to mind when you’re thinking about the best pizza in ohio, especially when you’re looking for something unique or artisanal. But let’s be real, sometimes you just want a big, cheesy slice of New York-style pizza, and Sbarro delivers on that front. It’s a classic mall food court staple, and there’s a certain nostalgia factor that’s hard to ignore. I mean, who hasn’t grabbed a slice while doing some shopping?

It’s definitely not the most gourmet option, and you probably won’t find it on any “best pizza in Newark Ohio” lists focusing on local gems, but for a quick, satisfying, and familiar slice, Sbarro does the trick. It’s consistent, it’s usually pretty cheap, and it’s available in a ton of locations. Sometimes, that’s all you need.

Look, Sbarro isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel. It’s straightforward, no-frills pizza. You know exactly what you’re getting, and there’s something comforting in that predictability. It’s the pizza equivalent of comfort food – not fancy, but always there when you need it.

Here’s a few reasons why Sbarro still has a place in the pizza world:

• Convenience: You can find it almost anywhere.
• Price: It’s generally pretty affordable.
• Consistency: The taste is pretty much the same no matter where you go.

9. Donatos Pizza

Donatos is a pretty well-known chain, and you can find them all over Ohio. It’s not some small, artisan place, but sometimes you just want something familiar and consistent. They’re known for their thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings, which is a nice change from some places that skimp.

I wouldn’t say it’s the best pizza in ohio if you’re looking for something super fancy, but it’s a solid choice for a quick and easy meal. Plus, they have a bunch of locations, so finding one is usually pretty simple. If you’re in pizza in newark ohio, you’re bound to find one close by.

Donatos is a reliable option when you need a quick pizza fix. It’s not going to blow your mind, but it’s consistently decent and hits the spot when you’re craving something simple.

Here’s a few reasons why people like Donatos:

• Consistent quality across locations
• Thin crust is a nice change of pace
• Lots of toppings to choose from

Donatos is a great option for a quick and easy pizza night.

10. Romeo’s Pizza

Romeo’s Pizza is a chain, but don’t let that fool you. They’ve got a pretty solid reputation, and you can find them all over Ohio. I’ve had Romeo’s a bunch of times, and it’s always a decent option when you’re craving something reliable. It’s not the most mind-blowing pizza in ohio, but it’s definitely a step up from some of the really basic chains out there. Plus, they usually have some pretty good deals going on, which is always a win.

Romeo’s is a good choice when you need something quick and easy. It’s not going to win any awards for innovation, but it’s a solid, dependable pizza that hits the spot. They’re all over the place, so finding one isn’t usually a problem, and their prices are pretty reasonable.

They have a location in Newark, Ohio, so if you’re looking for pizza in newark ohio, it’s worth checking out. They have a wide variety of toppings and crust options, so you can customize your pizza to your liking.

Here’s a few reasons why Romeo’s is a good choice:

• Consistent quality
• Wide availability
• Good value for money

Wrapping It Up: Your Next Pizza Adventure Awaits

So there you have it, our rundown of some of Ohio’s best pizza spots. We’ve gone from the old-school places to the ones doing new things with toppings and crusts. It’s pretty clear that Ohio has a lot to offer when it comes to good pizza. Whether you like your pie simple and classic or loaded with all sorts of stuff, there’s a place out there for you. Don’t just take our word for it, though. Get out there and try some of these places yourself. You might just find your new favorite slice. Happy eating!